Carpenter 158 vs 9310
Toolcraft Logo'd Carpenter 158 Nitride Full-Auto Bolt Carrier Group . Rating: 91%. Regular Price $129.99 Special Price $99.99. Add to Cart. Add to Wish List Add ... Available in either 9310 or C158 Steel Bolt. Toolcraft 5.56 NATO Black Nitride Bolt Carrier Group is a Full-Auto M16 BCG manufactured using the finest U.S-sourced raw materials. The Black Nitride coating vastly increases the hardness of the steel, prevents corrosion, is highly resistant to wear, will not flake (it’s not a coating, it’s a ...Made in USA. Bolt is made of Mil-spec Carpenter 158 steel, Shot peened, High pressure tested and Mag Particle Inspected. Gas key is machined out of bar stock, chrome lined phosphate coated, and secured with grade 8 fasteners and staked per mil-spec. Bolt carrier is phosphated outside and chrome lined inside. Laser engraved with the PSA logo.
Did you know?
The heat treatment process must be more closely controlled with 9310, from what I've read. I'm pretty sure Aermet 100 is a better steel than Carpenter 158 or SAE 9310. It's also made by Carpenter Technology Corporation. The Aermet 100 is about 3 times more expensive than Carpenter 158, but doesn't have lot minimums.Oct 6, 2020 ... The downside of 9310 steel is that is has to be properly heated treated when used for a bolt, and this process is one that is difficult with ...by comparison to Carpenter 158, AISI 9310 has several elements present in its composition that are detrimental to fatigue while not being evident in the physical properties. It has become evident from the industry that a number of manufacturers have jumped upon the AISI 9310 wagon in order to claim better performance. SKU: 5165449729 UPC: 5165449729 MFR#: 5165449729 Nickel Boron Finish Milspec Carpenter No. 158® steel bolt Shot Peened Bolt High pressure tested Mag particle inspected Gas Key Hardened to USGI Specifications Gas Key Grade 8 Hardened Fasteners Gas Key Staked Per Mil-Spec Tool Steel Extractor Extractor Spring Extractor O-ring Insert ToolCraft Logo PA-15 Engraving ToolCraft Premium Carpenter 158 ...Bren · #2 · Aug 21, 2019. I looked at a couple of PSA kits recently and the only difference was that one had a 9310 bolt and one had a C158. I doubt it makes any difference, but the C158 is the mil spec, so it has been tried and tested a lot more for a lot longer, so I went with that.19. C 158 vs 9310 Bolt. Just ordered a Aero Precision 6.5 bcg with bolt. Bolt is made of 158 carpenter instead of the 9310 i notice most others are. Is the 158 going to hold up fine its …Carpenter has never made or even tested a single bolt, and doesn't warranty any of the bolts manufactured using it's 158 steel. Conversely, LWD provides a lifetime guarantee on the bolt they engineered, tested, and manufactured using 9310. Carpenter's sales and profits are guaranteed by mil-spec mandates, regardless of final product performance ...Sep 6, 2023 · Strengths and Weaknesses of Both Steel Types. While 9310 Tool Steel and Carpenter Steel have exceptional properties, they also have weaknesses. 9310 Tool Steel is known to be brittle at room temperature, while Carpenter Steel has a lower resistance to corrosion and oxidation. If cost is a major consideration for your project, Carpenter Steel ... C 158 vs 9310 Bolt Just ordered a Aero Precision 6.5 bcg with bolt. Bolt is made of 158 carpenter instead of the 9310 i notice most others are. Is the 158 going to hold up fine its a hunting rig for a buddy that probly wont see a lot of rounds. Im sure ...Can somebody tell me what the difference is between c-158 and 9310 and why 9310 isn't mil-spec? I've seen 9310 used in some bolts and wonder if it's actually inferior. Is there technical data to show that c-158 is superior?Firearm Discussion and Resources from AR-15, AK-47, Handguns and more! Buy, Sell, and Trade your Firearms and Gear.by comparison to Carpenter 158, AISI 9310 has several elements present in its composition that are detrimental to fatigue while not being evident in the physical properties. It has become evident from the industry that a number of manufacturers have jumped upon the AISI 9310 wagon in order to claim better performance.In the case of the M16 family, the US military selected a steel called Carpenter 158 (also known as "C158" or "Car 158") to be used for manufacturing the bolt. Therefore, any AR15 or M16 bolts that claim to follow military specifications (or "mil-spec" for short) should be made of C158 steel as one of the requirements.It’s MPI tested and otherwise mil-spec…except that the bolt is made of 9310 steel instead of Carpenter 158. The chances of that mattering for an average shooter that puts even a few thousand rounds downrange a year is super slim. In the back of your mind, you’ll know it’s not mil-spec…but it’s about half the price of the BCM.19. C 158 vs 9310 Bolt. Just ordered a Aero Precision 6.5 bcg with bolt. Bolt is made of 158 carpenter instead of the 9310 i notice most others are. Is the 158 going to hold up fine its …Nov 8, 2016 · Where are you seeing bolts made from 8620, or carriers and keys made from C158 or 9310? The BCM website states the bolt is made from C158. PSA states this as well. The Nickel Boron BCG I was interested in, made by Ground Zero Precision, states the carrier is 8620 steel, bolt is C158, and the cam pin is 4340 steel. For each property being compared, the top bar is SAE-AISI 4140 steel and the bottom bar is SAE-AISI 9310 steel. SAE-AISI 4140 (SCM440, G41400) Cr-Mo Steel SAE-AISI 9310 (1.6657, G93106) Ni-Cr-Mo Steel. Metric Units US Customary Units. Mechanical Properties. Brinell Hardness: 200 to 310:AR15 Toolcraft Nickel Boron BCG - 9310 Steel -or- Carpenter 158 Steel Bolt, MPI Inspected, expertly machined, and a hassle free Lifetime Warranty! Track Your Order. Need Help? Menu. Reloading. Once Fired Brass. Commercial Range Brass; ... 9310 Steel. Carrier Material: 8620 Steel. Manufacturer:Thread: Carpenter 158 Vs. 9310. Thread Tools. Show Printable Version; 04-29-17, 14:46 #121. AR-556. View Profile View Forum Posts View Articles Member Join Date Aug 2016 Location The South Posts 190 Feedback Score 0. Originally Posted by Eurodriver.SAA AR-15 .223/5.56 Bolt Assembly Carpenter 158 - MPI Tested. Replacement Assembled Bolt for the .223/5.56/300AAC caliber AR-15 (or new builds). Assembled, Phosphate finished AR15 Bolt. Completely assembled with standard bolt parts: Extractor assembly, Ejector assembly, Gas Rings. Works with any AR15 standard Carrier of any finish (Phosphate ...Complete Black Nitride / Melonite Bolt Carrier Group. Smooth & Protective Nitride coating. M16 Carrier-8620 Bolt-9310 MPI & HPT Tested Shot Peened Upgraded ...Sep 5, 2023 · Among the various types of steel used in bolts, 9310 and C158 stand out as top contenders. Both are exceptionally strong and widely used in different industrial applications. This blog post will explore the properties, strengths, and limitations of 9310 …Can somebody tell me what the difference is between c-158 and 9310 and why 9310 isn't mil-spec? I've seen 9310 used in some bolts and wonder if it's actually inferior. Is there technical data to show that c-158 is superior?When comparing 8620 to Carpenter 158 you will notice that 158 has a much lower carbon content, and higher Chromium and Nickel content than 8620. 158 is truly an alloy metal, while 8620 is a low alloy metal. However in the world of steels that does not necessarily make it better but different.
May 12, 2016 · It has been the "Mil-Spec" since. Since the creation of Carpenter 158, the metals industry has continued to innovate, creating new blends of steels. 9310 is a AISI standard grade of tool steel that makes it about ~7% stronger than "mil-spec" Carpenter 158 steels, when appropriately treated. Jul 18, 2023 · The most common is Carpenter 158 or C-158 steel, and the second most popular is 9310 steel. The exact difference between them is a lot of scientific talk but the easy version is that 9310-steel is about 7% stronger than C-158 when heat treated correctly. However, C-158 is Mil-Spec. Why is C-138 Mil-Spec if there is something better out there? 158 Mil Spec which means 158 material is on the TDP but as soon as the next TDP holder submits this material change to 9310 the US Government will accept it, because there is not any durablity or function change. 158 is cheaper but 9310 can be purchased in lower amounts, which for most manufactures is even more important.Thread: Carpenter 158 Vs. 9310. Thread Tools. Show Printable Version; 04-29-17, 14:46 #121. AR-556. View Profile View Forum Posts View Articles Member Join Date Aug 2016 Location The South Posts 190 Feedback Score 0. Originally Posted by Eurodriver.
11-14-13, 06:26 #1 eperk Member Join Date Aug 2012 Location Northeast MS. Posts 460 Feedback Score 0 Carpenter 158 Vs. 9310 Can somebody tell me what the difference is between c-158 and 9310 and why 9310 isn't mil-spec? I've seen 9310 used in some bolts and wonder if it's actually inferior. Is there technical data to show that c-158 is superior?Forty years ago, John Carpenter released a horror movie called The Thing. In the early ‘80s, Hollywood seemed to be extremely interested in extraterrestrial life and the not-quite-human: in 1982 alone, three of the top 30 movies were E.T., ...IIRC, the original specifications for the GI issue model were for AQ-9310 (aircraft quality). The bolts were supposed to be good for 75K rounds, but most showed signs of cracking after 50-60K. ... The Carpenter 158 has to be purchased in 20,000 Lb lots and is roughly $5/Lb.…
Reader Q&A - also see RECOMMENDED ARTICLES & FAQs. Carpenter 158 is 9310 with case hardening It's not,. Possible cause: They are both excellent. 9310 has a small amount of molybdenum, 158 does not. 158 .
Bolt Carriers made from 8620 Steel, 6A1-4V Titanium or Aluminum. Keys made from 4130 Steel. Bolts available in 9310 Steel or Carpenter 158. Our products carry a lifetime warranty. Simply put Should any of our products fail, …PSA Freedom AR-15 Nitride Bolt Carrier Group With Carpenter 158 Bolt - 516446915 . Rating: 95%. Regular Price $129.99 Special Price $89.99. Add to Cart. Add to Wish List Add to Compare. PSA 20" Rifle-Length 6.5 Grendel 1/8 Stainless Steel Barrel & BCG Combo - …
C-158 is simply Carpenters trade name for P-6 tool steel. P-6 and 9310 are very close in composition. The 9310 has some molybedenum while the P-6 has more chrome and nickel. 9310 is about half the cost of P-6. Which is better? Don't know, I barely made it through that class. IMO, the heat treat is probably more important than the alloy …The Carpenter 158 has to be purchased in 20,000 Lb lots and is roughly $5/Lb. So I was wondering if there was another type of material out there that had the same chemical properties as the Carpenter 158, but could be purchased in smaller quantities (i.e. 1000 Lbs?)
May 4, 2013 ... C158 is harder and might be a better option for that For someone who wants become a carpenter, an associate’s degree or certificate to become employed in the profession is needed. Most carpenters need to learn and master basic carpentry skills through formal education and apprenticeships.Where are you seeing bolts made from 8620, or carriers and keys made from C158 or 9310? The BCM website states the bolt is made from C158. PSA states this as well. The Nickel Boron BCG I was interested in, made by Ground Zero Precision, states the carrier is 8620 steel, bolt is C158, and the cam pin is 4340 steel. Contact Us. 888-748-5252. Customize Your Shopping ExperienSAE 9310 is even harder and with C158 are popular in top ti Nov 16, 2013 · Now the bolts, they are made with AISI 9310 Steel, 9310 is better suited for an application such as a M16 bolt. 9310 is a steel typically used for gears, cams and …Can somebody tell me what the difference is between c-158 and 9310 and why 9310 isn't mil-spec? I've seen 9310 used in some bolts and wonder if it's actually inferior. Is there technical data to show that c-158 is superior? This premium backup bolt is a 9310 MPI spare bolt that perfec The bolt is essential in guiding the next round into the chamber, as well as ejecting the used cartridge after firing. Typically, the bolt is made of Carpenter 158 or 9310 Steel and consists of gas rings, an ejector, a bolt face, extractor, bolt body, and lugs. Gas Key or Bolt Carrier Key. This funnels gas from the gas tube into the carrier. Jul 17, 2014 · Posted: 7/17/2014 3:12:39 PM EDT. Sharps' RelWell, 9310 is actually around 7% stronger than CaAR15 Toolcraft Nickel Boron BCG - 9310 Steel -or- Handling firearms or firearms parts can expose you to lead and other petroleum products known to the State of California to cause cancer, birth defects, or ... Apr 13, 2012 Messages 156 Location Goose Creek, S.C. Think I read The SAE 9310 of the JP EnhancedBolt™ is a superior steel alloy in virtually every way compared to the C-158, whether in its resistance to structural failure or life expectancy, both of which far exceeding the Mil-spec. Just as with the transmission gears for Formula 1 racers which are also made from 9310, the operational demands of a bolt ...Nov 16, 2013 · Can somebody tell me what the difference is between c-158 and 9310 and why 9310 isn't mil-spec? I've seen 9310 used in some bolts and wonder if it's actually … The most common steel used in the bolt is Carpenter 15[SAE 9310 is even harder and with C158 are popular in top tier systePerhaps this is the wrong outlet to make this ques Posted: 7/17/2014 3:12:39 PM EDT. Sharps' Relia-Bolt has significantly come down on its price since its unveiling around the first of the year due to now being only $79.99. Being an S7 tool steel bolt with a NP3 finish for a hair less than $80, I decided to order one to try out in my upcoming build. I ordered it early Monday Morning, it shipped ...8620 Steel vs 9310. At first glance, it makes sense to compare these 2 steels. They’re both low alloy steels with nickel and chromium. But the 9310 steel is much more reliably stronger, and with greater toughness as well. It offers greater tensile strength and yield strength.